Sat 09 Aug 2008 // Brooklyn // New York is different

Today I went shopping at the most anarchic Target in America, the one on Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn. I wanted one of these:

Broom and dustpan photo

Shopping in our disastrous Target requires patience, compromise, and a willingness to be surprised. And surprised I was when I saw a man wearing a T-shirt that said “Welcome to America - Now speak English!

Whoa. I never thought I’d see anyone in Brooklyn wear that shirt. The shirt bothers me because it’s worn by those who can’t stand the idea of new people hanging around their town. It’s meant to be cruel. Of course new immigrants ought to learn English, but they have plenty of incentives to do so already. Putting it on a T-shirt seems kind of random, kind of obsessive. To quote the Big Lebowski: You’re not wrong, you’re just an asshole.

Most of all, it’s a pretty weird shirt to wear to the Brooklyn Target. All the Target signage is in English and Spanish, many customers and store employees are immigrants, and business is conducted in whatever language works. It’s an international community and nobody expects otherwise. (The Target mall sits around the block from, I kid you not, a Halal Chinese restaurant.)

The man in the “speak English” shirt was talking on a cell phone. As I approached him, I could hear clearly that he wasn’t speaking English. He was speaking what sounded like an Eastern European language. All of the sudden the shirt took on a whole new meaning. Either the guy couldn’t read what it said, or he read it as a joke and applied it to himself! Either way, I love it!

By the way, the Atlantic Avenue Target, which is always out of whatever I’m looking for, didn’t have any of these in stock:

Broom and dustpan photo

Instead, I bought one for $1.99 from one of those Spanish discount stores on Fifth Avenue.




6 Responses to “Running errands in Brooklyn”

tricia Says:

i HATE the brooklyn target. that target shouldn’t even be called target. it should be called “annoying store that is rarely stocked with anything useful, let alone anything on your shopping list.”




Anon Says:

I heard someone who lives in Brooklyn and wasn’t born in this country express a similar sentiment to that t-shirt the other day. Maybe it’s the whole I did it now you do it mentality.




Jess Says:

The Atlantic Terminal Target is no longer the only Target in town. Brooklyn Junction Target is but a bus ride away, and it feels like Target in another universe. It’s like going to the suburbs - everything is neatly organized and clean and in stock, and the aisles are wide and spacious and uncrowded.




Betsy Says:

I’ve met plenty of immigrants who get angry at other immigrants for not speaking English well. Go figure.

This reminds me of an issue I’m encountering at school. Foreign students complain about how hard it is to get a job after graduation and that the school doesn’t do much to help. They completely miss the point that the school WANTS THEM TO GO HOME AND IMPROVE THINGS AROUND THE WORLD (which is why they’re all on 100% scholarship). ARGH.




Renee Says:

“One of these” as in a broom and dustpan? Why can’t we just say broom and dustpan?




Daryl Lang Says:

Renee: Because, you know, it had to be that very specific type of broom and dustpan. Easier to show than explain.




Post a comment






30°F
Could be worse... You could be a turkey.